I have solid body guitars made of mahogany, swamp ash, alder, basswood, poplar, agathis, and ply. They all sound good and all sound different. I honestly don't have a favorite tone wood. I've repaired instruments for 25 years and I've found forums have myths about many things. More than you would think is by a product manufacture themselves under a sir name. They do this so you'll bypass their competition. It's done by guitar, pedal, and assorted gear makers. Below are photos of a Squier II ply guitar I got for $13 in a box of guitar parts. I took it down to the wood, refinished it and threw it back together. It weighs just over 4 pounds as you look at it in the photos. It sustains great and is a monster metal guitar because of the way I wired it. You wouldn't use it on songs by the Beatles or Rolling Stones. You could but, it would sound out of place because it doesn't want to do that.