So I found this thread (and more generally, the forum itself) last night, about six months after first unearthing the same videos people here have over a period of some 11+ years now.
This is great stuff. So painstaking, this process.
I was a very young kid when "Foreplay/Long Time" came out, but the entire Boston album is completely unforgettable to anyone with taste.
Before I decided at random to attack...er, master this song, I had never attempted anything close to its level of difficulty. I picked up serious playing in adulthood, and :really serious" playing during the pandemic. I have a Kurzweil PC361 that does everything I need it to do to hack through mostly '70s and '80s songs. My music theory knowledge itself far from comprehensive, greatly outstrips my playing ability.
It took me a day or more just to master the signature 6-note repeating sequence at the beginning.
Now, I can play what I call a passable full-speed version -- no mistakes noticeable to my dumbass friends -- about 1/3 of the time. If I played with a band making other noises to complement my own, I could get away with incorporating a veritable wealth of miscues
But that of course is antithetical to the entire point.
It will take me another few months to conquer the last 5% of the song, almost as long as it took to get to maybe 50% and again to 95%. It's always lonely at the top of anything.
What fundamentally drives me is grasping the sheer value of blind persistence. When I started running cross-country in 9th grade, I was average, but aspired in that weird environment to be the best--not in the world but in my smallish state. The path toward getting there--and I did get close--is a lot like this one. I can make up for a lack of talent or youth or whatever with garden-variety persistence....and a love, a real appreciating for every tangible step forward I can carry my musicianship.
For me the biggest sticking point is the measure right before the walkdown done twice (the triplets corresponding to G-flat, D-flat, E-flat and F).
Why? Because I don't like to practice! I could erase this deficit in a day, I bet. Maybe I will try today.
I also get this weird tendency to freeze in the last measure of the introduction, where you're holding the B-flat and walking the rest down. When my left 4th finger hits the C, my right hand really, really wants to bungle the six-note segment. I'll get over it.
For those with a chemistry background, to me, learning this is more like synthesizing a polymer from a limited set of monomers. I like that I can practice one part of the song in ways that helps the rest, which is not always the case.
Anyway, just appreciating the thread.