As a viewer, I can only speak about the performances.
It just looks like the band in the second video has a feeling of
"whatever" a gig's a gig, so what. They come across as basically playing the notes, and not much more. Phoning it in.
Overall, just a lack of passion.
That being said, we have no idea what was going on offstage with
the two bands, (rehearsals, lack of, management, day-jobs, family,etc) also pro-shot vs. home video does impact the viewer differently.
D