Hi!
The condition is⦠I'm a keyboard player of a jazz fusion / alternative rock band and need various kind of sounds (multitimbral synth, vintage keys, piano, acoustic instrument mockeryâ¦). But I also do the electronic music production (probably DnB?) and song arrangement as well.
I'm about to graduate from uni, and I've use school-owned studiologic digital piano for years (play with its inbuilt sound and use it as a controller for MainStage as well). I have to pick up my own keyboard now.
The gear / software I already have:
Roland INTEGRA-7. You may think it's a bit WTF to hold it if I don't own any keyboard controller and don't do much commercial composition:facepalm:. Yeah I unexpectedly got this with an extraordinary low price and I'm not sure if I should sell or keep it. IMO, It's basically a summit of 1990-2000s sounds and sounds good, got many out-of-box sounds for a keyboardist / EDM producer, but if I sell it, I could buy some squishy analog revival gear or software bundles like Ableton Live Suite or NI Komplete. MacBook Pro late 2013, with Logic Pro X and MainStage. Yeah it's currently the center of my workflow but it's getting old, the battery and SSD is dying, and it's performance is somewhat mediocre (2 Cores, 8GB RAM). I'm considering to save money for buying a new one. A Windows desktop. It's currently for gaming:facepalm:, got i7 8700 processor and 32GB of RAM. It could be my future production workhorse but I have to migrate to another DAW, and it's not for gigging. Maschine Mikro Mk2 (comes with some Kontakt libraries and Massive). I received it as a gift. Arturia V-Collection and Serum.
So, I got about $1200-1800 to spent on gear. Should I buy:
A workstation workhorse (like YAMAHA MODX7), and a budget tiny 32-49 keys MIDI keyboard (like Arturia Keystep) for production / solo / outdoor use
Or
Start with all-software workflow, purchase a premium controller like NI Komplete Kontrol S61 Mk2 and save money for software (like Ableton Live Suite or NI Komplete) and analog gear (like Korg Minilogue xd)?
If I choose the MODX7, Pros:
Overall good keyboard / synth sound for gigging, cut through the mix and easy to use, focus more on music and technique. Still a somewhat good controller with knobs, sliders and good keybed (no aftertouch, meh). Vintage keyboard and FM synth sounds are still competitive in production, and 8x16 parts ROMpler are interesting and useful in rehearsal / live.
Cons:
Japanese workstations are freaking overpriced and would eventually be obsolescence (YAMAHA: Yeah we've released MODX2! Worship gigging players and cover bands would definitely purchase a new one:facepalm:). Most onboard sounds are useless in production because Kontakt and software VA / analog synth can do way better.
If I choose all-software workflow, Pros:
Good VA and sample-based sound libraries, could use same gear for both gigging and production. MainStage and Live Suite are incredibly versatile and powerful. Analog gear like Korg Minilogue xd would not become obsolescence like it's workstation cater-cousins.
Cons:
Not very handy for gigging, especially on jamming / rehearsal scenario. It's a bit hard on mixing when use plug-ins from different vendor during live.
And⦠There may be a third way: purchase a budget digital piano / entry level workstation (like Korg Kross) for casual use / rehearsal and then go to the second way.
So what's your suggestion?