Music Player Network Home Guitar Player Magazine Keyboard Magazine Bass Player Magazine EQ Magazine
Page 1 of 1 1
Topic Options
#1003043 - 07/27/05 05:53 AM Format Wars
richiejazz
Senior Member


Registered: 06/03/05
Posts: 39

Offline
Was just wondering what everyone's take is on the DVD-A/SACD format war.... how many people have experienced surround sound music discs and what's the verdict????
_________________________
http://www.hairmusic.co.uk

Top
#1003044 - 07/27/05 05:55 AM Re: Format Wars
richiejazz
Senior Member


Registered: 06/03/05
Posts: 39

Offline
.......more to the point: - does anyone have any suggestions of an SACD compatible dvd rom drive for my pc?. I thought mine would play sacd files but now i dont think it does!!! I have just bought my first sacd (war of the worlds)I think all I can get is a quasi pro logic effect through the 6 speakers but not the true sacd surround that was intended.... any help much appreciated!!!!!
_________________________
http://www.hairmusic.co.uk

Top
#1003045 - 07/27/05 01:20 PM Re: Format Wars
doug osborne
MP Hall of Fame Member


Registered: 08/15/00
Posts: 2638
Loc: Culver City, CA, US

Offline
Quote:
Originally posted by richiejazz:
- does anyone have any suggestions of an SACD compatible dvd rom drive for my pc?.
Doesn't quite exist.

My computer DVD drive will play the CD layer of SA-CD discs, but not the SA-CD layer.

Philips has an expensive PCI card that will allow you to play DSD files through its analog outputs to a monitor system.

Philips has a Pro Tools DSD plugin that will help you produce audio in DSD format.

There may be hope: Steinberg/Yamaha has released ASIO 2.1, which has DSD support, and Sony has announced plans to release PCs using ASIO 2.1 as it's native audio format.

Things are slightly easier with DVD-A: Creative Labs, and a few others, have soundcards which will let you play a DVD-A disc (MLP encoded) through the soundcard to a surround monitor system, and these cards (although I wouldn't recommend them for audio production, they aren't bad) aren't hideously expensive.

Last week, some guy announced that he had cracked the DVD-A code and was offering free software to allow you to rip the MLP track from the Audio TS folder on a DVD-A... he was threatened with lawsuits and the sofware was withdrawn.

-----------------------

I just bought a universal disc player, a Samsung DVD-HD841 for less than $70, refurbished, from some guy on eBay, and it seems to work great. This will play DVD-A and SA-CD through its six analog outputs.

I have a wide collection of DVD-A and SA-CD discs. Both formats sound great, and both were imperfectly conceived. Either could have been a smash-hit consumer product had the industry united behind one and marketed it properly. This same industry is currently shooting itself in the foot and wondering why it hurts by allowing two HD disc formats, Blu Ray and HD-DVD, to come to market, thus confusing the consumer yet again.
_________________________
my day job

Top
#1003046 - 07/27/05 03:15 PM Re: Format Wars
richiejazz
Senior Member


Registered: 06/03/05
Posts: 39

Offline
Ah, so there isnt much scope in universal drives for pc's then.....

DVD-A certainly seems much easier. I have a an audigy 2 soundcard which came with DVD-A software and until a few days ago I didnt even know what to use it for! I bought my 1st sacd and thought this player might play it in 5.1 - but no luck. Then I found out about this format battle.
It seems sacd isnt as big here in europe as in the states - and they're rather hard to come by in shops.
What I really want is a drive that will play sacd for my computer (as that is where my 5.1 setup is) but I may have to settle for totally upgrading my tv unit with a player that plays dvd video/dvd-a/sacd (do these 'universal' players exist??)and a full home cinema surround setup with amp!!
_________________________
http://www.hairmusic.co.uk

Top
#1003047 - 07/27/05 09:30 PM Re: Format Wars
doug osborne
MP Hall of Fame Member


Registered: 08/15/00
Posts: 2638
Loc: Culver City, CA, US

Offline
Quote:
Originally posted by richiejazz:
...
It seems sacd isnt as big here in europe as in the states - and they're rather hard to come by in shops.
...
That's not just Europe, SA-CD and DVD-A just aren't very well-known.

Acoustic Sounds can be a great source (if they ship to Europe).
_________________________
my day job

Top
#1003048 - 07/28/05 08:13 AM Re: Format Wars
Neil Wilkes Moderator
Gold Member


Registered: 07/06/02
Posts: 514
Loc: London, UK

Offline
There is not now, and never will be (according to Sony/Philips) a Drive available for any computer that will play back SACD.
Why?
DRM.
The DVD-A copy protection system was uncracked (and pretty much still is) because of no soft players being made available that can be reverse engineered.
Now WinDVD is DVD-A capable, all of a sudden there is a set of tools to extract the tracks from the discs using hacked WinDVD files.
They are not true rips, but recordings of the streams output from WinDVD. But it is still there, and still wrong.
Sony/Philips refuse to allow this.

SACD also has a serious amount of ultrasonic noise above 23KHz present in it. This is often got rid of by use of LPF set to 23KHz in the players decoders, but when it is missing the results are horrendous. Anyone who wants proof is welcome to mail me for a JPG file of a spectrum/frequency plot of an SACD output, taken from a reference quality Sony machine's outputs. The noise is clearly there.
With DVD-A at 24/96, there is no such noise present in the output.

IMHO, DVD-A is the superior format - plus it is far more accessible to the little guy. You cannot now and never will be able to make an SACD disc yourself. It has to be done through a replication facility. DSD is not SACD. It is the file format the Audio uses, nothing more. Same way that PCM is not DVD-A either.
_________________________
http://www.opusproductions.com

Top
#1003049 - 07/28/05 11:48 AM Re: Format Wars
doug osborne
MP Hall of Fame Member


Registered: 08/15/00
Posts: 2638
Loc: Culver City, CA, US

Offline
Quote:
Originally posted by Neil Wilkes:
There is not now, and never will be (according to Sony/Philips) a Drive available for any computer that will play back SACD.
...
wrong

Sony Europe Announces First PC With DSD, ASIO 2.1 and Blu-Ray Disc

Quote:
At the recent Musikmesse 2005 Show, Sony's IT Europe Division announced what they are calling the World's First PC with three cutting edge technologies.


PCs with Direct Stream Digital (DSD), Steinberg's Audio Stream Input/Output (ASIO) 2.1 and a Blu-Ray Disc Drive, will be known as Sound Reality by VAIO and are scheduled to be available for purchase by the end of 2005.


Sony officials say that the combination of these three technologies into one PC will address the needs of several groups they call "the music professional, the home studio user and the enthusiastic domestic music consumer".

Direct Stream Digital (DSD)
High Fidelity Review readers are familiar with Direct Stream Digital or DSD technology. It was developed by Sony and Philips and is the underpining of their Super Audio CD (SACD) disc system as well as a new recording and archiving technology for recording engineers, mastering engineers, recording artists and studios.

Serge Stevenart, Manager, New Technologies at Sony IT Europe says that "DSD effectively re-wrote the audio standards when it was introduced in 1999, creating a new benchmark for high-resolution surround sound but until now it has only been available for use in the professional audio industry sector. Now, we have achieved the same high audio standard within the PC environment. We have products scheduled for 2005 which will integrate this technology. They target the needs of a range of audio groups from the professional user to Home Studio prosumers and consumers that wish to upgrade their CD (stereo PCM)-based music collections to fully featured high-resolution surround sound that will play back at high quality on their home entertainment systems.

DSD is revolutionising the audio industry and Sony?s Sound Reality initiative is an important bridge to the future of high-resolution audio in the PC environment. Whether it?s used in the home, home studio or a professional music recording environment, Sony Sound Reality represents an important milestone in the convergence of AV and IT technology."

Steinberg's Audio Stream Input/Output (ASIO) 2.1 Adds DSD
Another key part of the Sound Reality by VAIO PC line is the use of the new 2.1 version of the Audio Stream Input/Output standard developed by Steinberg.

Steinberg is a German firm that makes several popular PC based Digital Audio editing software programs for the Home and Pro Studio market including Nuendo, Cubase and WaveLab. The programs are in wide use for Stereo and Surround Sound work by top engineers including Elliot Scheiner and Chuck Ainlay.

Sony and Steinberg describe ASIO as "a cross-platform, multi-channel audio transfer protocol that is being adopted by many of the manufacturers of audio/MIDI (Musical Instrument Digital Interface) sequencing applications. It allows software to have access to the multi-channel capabilities of a wide range of powerful sound cards.

ASIO expands on the basic capabilities of a standard computer sound card, most of which can only provide stereo (two-channel) audio input and output. The ASIO specification defines the interface that manufacturers of professional audio sound cards must use to create an ASIO driver for their hardware. This driver allows the host audio/MIDI application to "see" all of the inputs and outputs available on the sound card. The user can then assign these I/O ports as needed for recording or playback when using an ASIO-compatible software program. This allows the users to record more tracks simultaneously than the previous limitation of two channels imposed by a standard sound card.

The Audio Stream Input/Output (ASIO) architecture forms the backbone of Steinberg?s Virtual Studio Technology. ASIO supports variable bit depths and sample rates, multi-channel operation and synchronization. The user gets low latency, high performance, easy set up and stable audio recording within VST. The entire system becomes controllable and offers complete and immediate access to the audio system's capabilities. Since its introduction, ASIO has become a supported standard by many leading audio hardware manufacturers."

With ASIO 2.1, the protocol "now supports DSD delivery between all DSD-ready hardware and software". The Software Development Kit (SDK) for ASIO 2.1 with DSD is now available for downloading from the Steinberg web site. Steinberg says that the addition of Direct Stream Digital to ASIO 2.1 was accomplished "following an intense technological cooperation with Sony".

Claus Menke, Steinberg?s Head of Product Management says that "At Steinberg we are firmly committed to developing open and inclusive audio technologies. DSD support within ASIO opens up new possibilities for audio application and hardware manufacturers to include DSD in their products."

A One-Chip DSD Processor and DSD Upsampling
Sony says that the Sound Reality by VAIO PC will include a one-chip DSD processor. This will offload the DSD audio processing to minimize the impact on the PC's CPU performance.

Also included will be a new edition of Sonic Stage Mastering Studio software from Sony. According to Sony, the new version "empowers the user to record, playback and edit music in both DSD and PCM (Pulse Code Modulation) audio formats. Its PCM recording capability is critical since this is CD?s core enabling technology. Users can take a standard stereo CD, rip it to their PC hard drive and then use their Sound Reality PC to up-convert the audio signal to a fully uncompressed DSD audio stream."

Blu-Ray Disc Drive
Sony officials also indicated that the Sound Reality by VAIO PC will feature a Blu-Ray Disc drive. This isn't surprising since several of the Blu-Ray licensees at January's CES 2005 show (HP, Pioneer and Sony) indicated that they planned to offer Blu-Ray Disc ROM Drives (also known as BD-ROM Drives) for PC use by the end of 2005. That prediction appears to be coming true - although one wonders if the recent talk of a unified Blu-Ray/HD-DVD format might slow the timetable a bit.

SACD Playback?
While the new Sound Reality by VAIO PC offers many features, one thing that it apparently won't have is SACD disc playback. For that, the PC would need an SACD enabled drive. To date, there hasn't been any mention of such a feature from Sony.

We'll keep an eye out to see if future entries in the upcoming Sound Reality by VAIO PC line bring that to the table as well. In the meantime, with features including DSD, ASIO and Blu-Ray, the Sound Reality PC could be a very interesting item for audio fans at year's end.

_________________________
my day job

Top
#1003050 - 07/29/05 08:29 AM Re: Format Wars
Neil Wilkes Moderator
Gold Member


Registered: 07/06/02
Posts: 514
Loc: London, UK

Offline
Sorry Doug, but you are wrong here.
As it says in the second last paragraph of what you have quoted too.
A drive or PC that has DSD capability is still not going to play an SACD.
SACD is not the same as DSD - it is related in the same way PCM is related to DVD-A and CD, and playback of a WAV file is not the same thing as playback of a DVD-A disc.

Neither is a DSD capable computer going to play back an SACD disc.

As for computer BluRay, it will be so fragile as to be useless. The 0.1 mm technology means a fingerprint on the surface will throw the focus out. Inferior garbage from Sony - again.
_________________________
http://www.opusproductions.com

Top
#1003051 - 07/29/05 08:30 AM Re: Format Wars
blas
Gold Member


Registered: 03/06/01
Posts: 517
Loc: St. Louis, MO. USA

Offline
Doug, Good information. You do keep an ear to the ground for those of us more 'earless' about the coming's and going's in the industry.
Neil, I know your great passion for the DVD-A format but do have to say- shame on both sides!
These companies made me sad. Because of their selfish reasons, would rather let this fish lay on the shore and die a slow death than come to terms with each other and help the creature get back to cool waters.
I have SACD in my home and DVD-A in my car. I love 'em both...surround sound is a beautiful thing.
Blas

Top
#1003052 - 07/29/05 08:35 AM Re: Format Wars
Neil Wilkes Moderator
Gold Member


Registered: 07/06/02
Posts: 514
Loc: London, UK

Offline
Blas.
I have a downer on DSD and SACD simply because of the massive amopunts of ultrasonic noise present in the system. All that is above 23KHz in SACD is noise, which makes a lie out of the supposed massive bandwidth.
It is a single bit system from a 2 bit company fuelling a 3rd rate format.
You still have to use PCM to mix the music, as you cannot mix/EQ/add FX in DSD/Single bit format - it is not possible. So all claims about superiority are from the same people that brought the Emperors New Clothes.

Check out some of John Watkinsons articles about SACD/DSD in Resolution magazime (www.resolutionmag.com) - he knows his Digits, and thinks the same way I do. As do a lot of the AES.
DSD is bad - very bad.
_________________________
http://www.opusproductions.com

Top
#1003053 - 07/29/05 10:45 AM Re: Format Wars
m2_dup1
Platinum Member


Registered: 02/04/04
Posts: 1331
Loc: New York

Offline
Neil,

with all due respect, calling DSD very bad is ridiculous. I've heard DSD and it sounded absolutely wonderful. The best sonic experience I've ever heard in my entire life (that wasn't a live performance of course).

I heard no noise (to be expected, right?) and the imaging and overall realism was stunning.

I'm not saying DVD-A isn't be better from a technical standpoint. I'm not even saying it doesn't sound "better". But calling DSD / SACD 'very bad' is simply an overstatement.
_________________________
I wish you were ron jeremy....

Top
#1003054 - 07/29/05 11:00 AM Re: Format Wars
doug osborne
MP Hall of Fame Member


Registered: 08/15/00
Posts: 2638
Loc: Culver City, CA, US

Offline
Quote:
Originally posted by Neil Wilkes:
Sorry Doug, but you are wrong here.
As it says in the second last paragraph of what you have quoted too.
...
OK (I try not to post stuff like this...), but I have information from a reliable source, to whom I can not attribute this, that this line of VAIOs will not come out as planned unless they play SA-CD. The likelyhood of their release is about 50% at this point because Sony probably will quietly, passively abandon SA-CD as a consumer release format.
_________________________
my day job

Top
#1003055 - 07/31/05 04:58 AM Re: Format Wars
Neil Wilkes Moderator
Gold Member


Registered: 07/06/02
Posts: 514
Loc: London, UK

Offline
Then this line of VIAO will never come out.
Sony/Philips will never allow computer based SACD drives because it will allow people to breach the copy protection in just the same way has now been done with WinDVD and DVD-A. All that is now unbroken is the watermarking.

As for SACD being dropped, I don't much care personally as I prefer DVD-A - which is far from "dead".
_________________________
http://www.opusproductions.com

Top
#1003056 - 07/31/05 01:33 PM Re: Format Wars
doug osborne
MP Hall of Fame Member


Registered: 08/15/00
Posts: 2638
Loc: Culver City, CA, US

Offline
Quote:
Originally posted by Neil Wilkes:
Then this line of VIAO will never come out.
That's what I'm thinkin'.
_________________________
my day job

Top
#1003057 - 07/31/05 05:56 PM Re: Format Wars
richiejazz
Senior Member


Registered: 06/03/05
Posts: 39

Offline
So am I right in saying from the above info that no VAIOs yet have sacd caompatible playback???

Also this whining about copyright issues (like the concerns from DVD-A) is surely just pathetic. Sony should get their act together. Am I right in saying DVD-A isnt actually copyable, it has just been 'recorded' from the source creating a different outcome?
God this issue is giving me a headache!!
_________________________
http://www.hairmusic.co.uk

Top
#1003058 - 08/01/05 06:05 AM Re: Format Wars
Neil Wilkes Moderator
Gold Member


Registered: 07/06/02
Posts: 514
Loc: London, UK

Offline
There are no computers available with SACD playback. Period. Not now, not ever.

As for "Whining about copyright issues", I take that to mean you don't believe that the people who make the records should actually get paid then? The idea is necessary in these days to prevent theft of content. Otherwise some moron will upload an image to usenet, and sales will immediately fall even lower. Everyone who uploads a rip of anything for free that is currently available to buy, is hurting our business and should be stopped from doing this with every and all necessary means available.
_________________________
http://www.opusproductions.com

Top
#1003059 - 08/01/05 11:52 AM Re: Format Wars
richiejazz
Senior Member


Registered: 06/03/05
Posts: 39

Offline
You know full well that is only one side of the arguement. I for one am not a thief: I am also in the music business. The internet has introduced me to literally thousands of artists and technologies that I would not have looked at twice at if they werent there online and this has made me go out and buy these said items. (the music industry assumes that everyone is out to get them on this and they underestimate the mass of true music fans!)
Also I for one, like many of my friends and I imagine millions of people, rely on my computer as an all round entertainment unit (tv, dvd, and most importantly MUSIC) Now, I have no intention whatsoever to waste money buying one of these stand alone sacd players unless perhaps a universal drive was available for my pc - therefore im not going to be buying any sacds. Wheres the corporation profit in that??? Now as for sales falling lower, do you actually KNOW that so called breeches of copyright losses are a bigger concern than people being genuinly not arsed with the technology and being unprepared to commit??? I dont see how even the closest estimation could answer that question.
And so leading me to my final point:

Quote
"Everyone who uploads a rip of anything for free that is currently available to buy, is hurting our business and should be stopped from doing this with every and all necessary means available."

So does this justify sony 'hiding' this technology from the public??? Is that their overwhelming distribution goal? Nothing will ever be totally safe from being ripped, and people who think otherwise are very naive. Sony might be happy with the current "cult" status of the sacd, but I hear (correct me if wrong) that they are going to wash their hands of the format shortly....shooting themselves in the foot
Now to me, leaving the science of the 2 formats aside for a sec, SACD seems a better format or at least a better idea to that of DVD-A. However I understand (again correct me if wrong) that DVD-A is far more popular and is deemed to have greater longevity compared to its rival, even though it not as simple as putting it in a ordinary cd player. Is this surprising??? I admit I am a newcomer to this format war (and so my opinions will probably be declared void) but so far I have easily been able to obtain units to play dvd-a on all sorts of systems without any difficulty, including my computer and players that i didnt even no were capable of such! I bought my first sacds the other week and have not been able to find anywhere to play the enhanced multichannel sound without spending a great wad of cash on something which , by the looks of things, would not be a wise investment anyway!
The key to marketing here is the ease of distribution... DVD-A EASY sacd NOT

There you go, rant over.
_________________________
http://www.hairmusic.co.uk

Top
#1003060 - 08/02/05 09:24 AM Re: Format Wars
Neil Wilkes Moderator
Gold Member


Registered: 07/06/02
Posts: 514
Loc: London, UK

Offline
Some interesting arguments.
However, my opinion here is that whilst it might be desirable to you to have a universal drive in a PC that will play everything, this is not shared - rightly or wrongly - by Sony. Even though I genuinely do not like SACD at all, I admire Sony's determination here.
As for formats not taking off, I doubt very much that this is due to indifference, but most likely down to the makers themselves.
Nobody in their right mind wants to get stuck with the next betamax in their homes, and continual talk of "The next big thing" with regard to Blu Ray is killing things before they get started. Why invest in a system that is going to be superseded in a couple of years (according to the makers)?
Also, Sony's development of DSD did not help either. They own some of the DVD-A patents, yet due to a commercial decision not to release high Res in any other format than their own proprietary one, Sony are making the exact same errors that were made in the Quad era. With 4 different incompatible vinyl systems, it is surprising perhaps that Quad lasted as long as it did. We are making the exact same mistakes all over again.

And not all SACD can be played in a CD player either - not all are hybrids by any means.

Finally, saying that "nothing is safe from being ripped" and therefore by inference stating DRM is pointless, can I ask you if you lock the doors of your home when you go out? I bet you do. But why bother? After all, any lock can be picked.....
It is there to keep people honest as far as possible. Period. Don't make it easy and they will go burgle someone else, right? Same applies to DRM.
There is a usenet group where within 5 days of release there were ripped DTS versions of all DVD-A titles being downloaded by the hundreds. Every one a lost sale. This is not good, and cannot ever be percieved as good. Digital media needs to be protected.
_________________________
http://www.opusproductions.com

Top
#1003061 - 08/02/05 04:34 PM Re: Format Wars
richiejazz
Senior Member


Registered: 06/03/05
Posts: 39

Offline
Yeagh I agree with those words: mistakes do seem to being made over again in light of concern over the next big thing.
As for ripping: I am stil very open to both sides of the ripping debate. I did not mean to infer that DRM is pointless: of course digital data should be protected, I just get the feeling that the copyright thing is turning into the whole compensation claim obsession this country is going through!! Also autorities are gradually clamping down on such internet copies and I think people are genuinely wary about it. DVD-A's are doing alright though arent they?
I guess im just pissed off cause im a sucker for sound detail and quite excited about possible new formats. Im also very poor!!!!and will have to buy an sacd player for my new discs and im worried it will be useless next year.

BTW I heard (perhaps wrongly) that with the DVD-A rips, they were simply 'recorded' while being played on a computer therfore not actually "ripped". Apparently normally you cant do this (i noticed a warning message come up about this when i first opened the dvd audio player on my pc) Surely, though if thats the case, then the rip is pointless as it defies the point of capturing the quality of dvd-as??
_________________________
http://www.hairmusic.co.uk

Top
#1003062 - 08/06/05 09:31 AM Re: Format Wars
richiejazz
Senior Member


Registered: 06/03/05
Posts: 39

Offline
BTW to some up this whole debuckle - is the saviour and answer to all our problems 'DualDisc'???? Discuss
_________________________
http://www.hairmusic.co.uk

Top
#1003063 - 08/06/05 09:09 PM Re: Format Wars
doug osborne
MP Hall of Fame Member


Registered: 08/15/00
Posts: 2638
Loc: Culver City, CA, US

Offline
DualDisc would be a great interim format if it was truly universal, but its thickness keeps it from working in some CD players.

DualDisc can contain DVD-A material, but I'm not sure that anyone has released a DD with a surround mix in MLP, only Dolby Digital.

DD certainly is a value-added product, giving more to the consumer than a download (paid-for or not) can.

Sony is issuing quite a few DualDiscs, and none have DSD on the DVD layer, although I'm sure that they could, technologically. I think that pretty much sums up Sony's support for SA-CD.
_________________________
my day job

Top
#1003064 - 08/07/05 09:00 AM Re: Format Wars
Neil Wilkes Moderator
Gold Member


Registered: 07/06/02
Posts: 514
Loc: London, UK

Offline
Doug - there have been a fair few DualDisc releases with DVD-A content in MLP.
See http://www.quadraphonicquad.com forums, and go to the High Rez spotlight section.
In the DVD-A section there is a stack of releases in DualDisc/DVD-A format.
There is a separate section for DD DualDiscs - Sony releases naturally - and all but Sony are using DVD-A as the DVD side for titles.
Beck's Guero, Diana Krall - Girl in the Other Room, many more.

Sony cannot put DSD on the DVD layer of a DualDisc, as it would not be a DualDisc then, would it! DualDisc states clearly the content has to be DVD, and originally it was to be DVD-A until guess who? Yes, Sony - watered it all down again.
_________________________
http://www.opusproductions.com

Top
#1003065 - 08/07/05 10:20 AM Re: Format Wars
richiejazz
Senior Member


Registered: 06/03/05
Posts: 39

Offline
Ahh more confusion!!!!
Yes but the surround quality from DD is equally as good isnt it, because its mostly DVD-A stuff - just with the, usually, added bonus of sacd's trick of being cd player compatible.
_________________________
http://www.hairmusic.co.uk

Top
#1003066 - 08/07/05 05:06 PM Re: Format Wars
doug osborne
MP Hall of Fame Member


Registered: 08/15/00
Posts: 2638
Loc: Culver City, CA, US

Offline
Thanks!

Quote:
Originally posted by Neil Wilkes:
...all but Sony are using DVD-A as the DVD side for titles.
Beck's Guero, ...
I have Gureo on the double disc set, not the DualDisc (as richiejazz understates...confusion). The second disc, that is clearly labeled DVD Audio/Video, has among other things what appear to be MLP encoded 24/48 surround mixes and DD surround mixes. The MLP sounds much better (although I had to evaluate with different players) than the AC3.

The last few DVD-As from DTS (including Porcupine Tree) are similar.
_________________________
my day job

Top
#1003067 - 08/08/05 05:32 AM Re: Format Wars
Neil Wilkes Moderator
Gold Member


Registered: 07/06/02
Posts: 514
Loc: London, UK

Offline
Quote:
Originally posted by richiejazz:
Ahh more confusion!!!!
Yes but the surround quality from DD is equally as good isnt it, because its mostly DVD-A stuff - just with the, usually, added bonus of sacd's trick of being cd player compatible.
Not even close to as good as uncompressed (as in lossy compression) MLP.
Dolby Digital throws out almost as much information as MP3 does - you are left with about 1/12 of the original information.
Plus you absolutely must set the correct dialnorm options, or the null bands are all out of whack too. And correct setting of dialnorm presumes a Dolby 737 meter - or a correctly weighted Leq(m) weighting meter.
Next to a 24/96 - or even a 24/48 MLP stream, the detail & openness compared to Dolby Digital is awesome. I personally loathe the DD compression - artifacts all over the place once you know what to listen for they are obvious.

DTS is better by a long, long way although still not perfect. Both systems will benefit from 24 bit source material over 16 bit. But true DVD-A is simply streets ahead.

Doug.
The Porcupine Tree releases are not DualDisc, at least here in the UK.
There is an MLP surround in the Audio_TS, plus DTS surround & LPCM stereo in the Video_TS folder for compatibility, meaning the disc will play on all DVD players. There are CD versions of these 2 albums, but I do not know the content.
DVD-A/V is not the same as DualDisc, although it is possible to put a DVD-A/V side on a dualdisc as long as it remains a single layer side.
_________________________
http://www.opusproductions.com

Top
#1003068 - 08/08/05 05:33 AM Re: Format Wars
Neil Wilkes Moderator
Gold Member


Registered: 07/06/02
Posts: 514
Loc: London, UK

Offline
(Double Post - sorry!)
_________________________
http://www.opusproductions.com

Top
#1003069 - 08/08/05 05:34 AM Re: Format Wars
Neil Wilkes Moderator
Gold Member


Registered: 07/06/02
Posts: 514
Loc: London, UK

Offline
Quote:
Originally posted by richiejazz:
[qb] Ahh more confusion!!!!
Yes but the surround quality from DD is equally as good isnt it, because its mostly DVD-A stuff - just with the, usually, added bonus of sacd's trick of being cd player compatible.
Not even close to as good as uncompressed (as in lossy compression) MLP.
Dolby Digital throws out almost as much information as MP3 does - you are left with about 1/12 of the original information.
Plus you absolutely must set the correct dialnorm options, or the null bands are all out of whack too. And correct setting of dialnorm presumes a Dolby 737 meter - or a correctly weighted Leq(m) weighting meter.
Next to a 24/96 - or even a 24/48 MLP stream, the detail & openness compared to Dolby Digital is awesome. I personally loathe the DD compression - artifacts all over the place once you know what to listen for they are obvious.
Also, there is no CD player compatibility at all on a DVD-A disc, and also not on a lot of SACD discs either.

DTS is better by a long, long way although still not perfect. Both systems will benefit from 24 bit source material over 16 bit. But true DVD-A is simply streets ahead.

Doug.
The Porcupine Tree releases are not DualDisc, at least here in the UK.
There is an MLP surround in the Audio_TS, plus DTS surround & LPCM stereo in the Video_TS folder for compatibility, meaning the disc will play on all DVD players. There are CD versions of these 2 albums, but I do not know the content.
DVD-A/V is not the same as DualDisc, although it is possible to put a DVD-A/V side on a dualdisc as long as it remains a single layer side.
_________________________
http://www.opusproductions.com

Top
Page 1 of 1 1


Moderator:  BobbyO, Neil Wilkes 
Hop to:
Support Your Forums