Music Player Network Home Guitar Player Magazine Keyboard Magazine Bass Player Magazine EQ Magazine
Page 1 of 2 1 2 >
Topic Options
#2901018 - 01/09/18 11:03 PM Who of you play to a click?
JimboK Offline
Senior Member

Registered: 03/04/08
Posts: 348
Loc: California
So my guitar and bass player banded together to talk myself, drummer and singer into playing to a click. I knew we had some occasional tempo issues, but never bugged me much. Drummer was amiable so I programmed all my combi's (Kronos) to push a metronome to an assignable out. We ended up putting them in everyone's in ears.

Wow, turns out I love it! Tightens up the whole band significantly. No "excitement speed" issues. Songs have room to breathe. Vocals are never rushed. Even my key parts seem easier.

Had to go get a midi solutions foot switch controller so both drummer and I can mute the click (well he mutes as needed with pedal, I run the click start/stop).

Anyone else do this or are we cheating horribly?
_________________________
Korg Kronos 61, Dave Smith Mopho x4, 1954 Hammond C2, Wurlitzer 200A, Yamaha Motif 6, Casio CDP-100, Alesis Vortex Wireless

Top
KC Island
#2901021 - 01/09/18 11:17 PM Re: Who of you play to a click? [Re: JimboK]
RudyS Offline
MP Hall of Fame Member

Registered: 11/06/02
Posts: 2158
Loc: Groningen, The netherlands
We play with a click in 80% of our songs. Also because there are backing tracks. The click is only send to the drummer though..
_________________________
Rudy

Stuff: Nord Electro 3, Casio PX5s, DSI Mopho keys, Nord Lead A1, Korg N5, Korg Poly 61, QSC K10 and a Shure SM58.

Top
#2901024 - 01/10/18 12:07 AM Re: Who of you play to a click? [Re: JimboK]
MathOfInsects Online   content
MP Hall of Fame Member

Registered: 02/04/15
Posts: 3108
Loc: California
Originally Posted By: JimboK
No "excitement speed" issues.


I don't see this as a bad thing.
_________________________
"

Top
#2901026 - 01/10/18 01:12 AM Re: Who of you play to a click? [Re: MathOfInsects]
GRollins Offline
Gold Member

Registered: 09/01/17
Posts: 897
While I can see using a click track while recording, I'm not sold on the idea of using one live. It's your band and your performance--if it floats your boat, go for it.

Grey
_________________________
I'm not interested in someone's ability to program. I'm interested in their ability to compose and play.

Top
#2901027 - 01/10/18 02:18 AM Re: Who of you play to a click? [Re: GRollins]
ksoper Offline
MP Hall of Fame Member

Registered: 10/17/00
Posts: 3139
Loc: Murfreesboro,TN,UNITED STATES
In one artist gig I did the drummer played to a click that no one else heard and we played to him. It was awesome. Another artist gig the drummer used the blinking light of a drum machine as a click. He sucked. He was in time as long as he watched the light but when he played a fill his time went to hell.

In the studio I prefer using a click and making the parts feel good around it. Live, it depends on the drummer.

Top
#2901029 - 01/10/18 02:31 AM Re: Who of you play to a click? [Re: GRollins]
I-missRichardTee Offline
MP Hall of Fame Member

Registered: 09/04/11
Posts: 6624
Loc: S. Ca. USA
I am old enough to share this.

I recorded with the big boys in NYC as a sub bassist. I recall when there was no such thing as a click.. and then I recall when one day I had that click in the phones .
(I generally only used one ear in the phone , the other in the atmosphere of the studio.)

Not sure what to say about it that is definitive. But I am experienced and opinionated based on those many experiences .. so I will try.

There are a few things I can say such as, for jazz or blues or gospel, or Latin music, it would be kind of verboten,,( not cool, for those of you who are not German) to use a click!

Playing in perfect time has two meanings, one with the click, but another .. the way musicians played for millennia ( a really long long time with no dumb click ), with the natural heart pulse. Based on simple arithmetic, most music is click less.

I think the click was introduced because vast majority of drummers sucked at tempo.
But that blame could be said about the rest of the band.

Another comment... It is indelible in my mind, the day a new singer subbed for our regular singer. The profound effect the new singer had on the groove... if you had asked me this, I would have said, no way, can a singer influence groove the way a bass or drum can., but that sub singer showed me I was naive.. a melody person, has a huge effect on groove. Think your average tempo deficient singer,than fast forward to Sinatra or James Brown.

I am obsessive about tempo change, thanks to the good news bad news of working with top session guys who had the best control of tempo and groove ever in my experience.

The mixed blessing of being super sensitive to tempo has dogged me my whole life.
I would give anything to play with a great drummer or great rhythm guitar and great drummer.. the stuff that great bands are made of.

Now, I have been kind of "forced" to play with a drum machine.. and I can comment on that.

it is difficult to perfectly breath with a click. I have rarely accomplished perfect sync with a drum machine.. the few times I did accomplish perfect melding with click, it was a magnificent high.
But so is matching up with a drummer sans click!

You lose out with click playing, because you lose the natural speeding up slowing down that is natural to musicians.
Learning how to play perfectly with a click is good for you
But one should not solely depend on it.. you have to develop your own clock too.

Any questions? rimshot
_________________________
Either there is or is not a high purpose for Life.

Top
#2901030 - 01/10/18 02:31 AM Re: Who of you play to a click? [Re: ksoper]
Throbert Offline
Gold Member

Registered: 01/22/09
Posts: 826
Loc: Colorado
doesn't need to be a click, a beat with subtle cues for reference can help keep things more life like.
_________________________
Triton Extreme 76, Kawai ES3, GEM RPX, Lynx Aurora 8/AES16e,
MSI Z97 MPower/4790K, OP-X PRO-II, Pianotec, Komplete 5. I need
a UAD quad, an HX3 module, Drawbar controller and an IEM rig. More VIs

Top
#2901033 - 01/10/18 02:47 AM Re: Who of you play to a click? [Re: Throbert]
mcgoo Offline
MP Hall of Fame Member

Registered: 11/03/07
Posts: 2368
Loc: Indianapolis
I do both, depending on the band, the style of music and even the song. One advantage to playing to a click, is that you can safely use an arpeggiator live.
_________________________
Somehow I manage to con people into paying me to play with toys that make noise.

Top
#2901043 - 01/10/18 04:57 AM Re: Who of you play to a click? [Re: I-missRichardTee]
Synthoid Offline
10k Club

Registered: 12/04/03
Posts: 10223
Loc: Pennsylvania, USA
Originally Posted By: I-missRichardTee
I think the click was introduced because vast majority of drummers sucked at tempo.

I would give anything to play with a great drummer or great rhythm guitar and great drummer.. the stuff that great bands are made of.

You lose out with click playing, because you lose the natural speeding up slowing down that is natural to musicians.

Learning how to play perfectly with a click is good for you
But one should not solely depend on it.. you have to develop your own clock too.


All of these are excellent points. And looking at number one... I've been extremely fortunate to play in bands with above average drummers. It provides a great rhythmic foundation.

However, a couple months ago I played with a drummer who just couldn't create a decent groove. It was almost excruciating at times. I eventually stopped playing and explained what we needed... adding some verbal noises and "clicks."

That helped. Sort of.

He's really a great guy and has played for years. Not sure what happened. frown

_________________________
To stop the flow of music would be like the stopping of time itself, incredible and inconceivable.
-- Aaron Copland

Top
#2901051 - 01/10/18 06:10 AM Re: Who of you play to a click? [Re: I-missRichardTee]
Bobadohshe Offline
MP Hall of Fame Member

Registered: 12/25/06
Posts: 5768
Loc: San Diego / Los Angeles
Originally Posted By: I-missRichardTee

I think the click was introduced because vast majority of drummers sucked at tempo.


Another reason people track with a click is because it makes DAW editing after the fact so much easier. I cut my entire album to click even though it was a funky jazz album and had great drummers including our mutual friends Tee: Zak Najor (and his brother Jake). This made it so much easier to edit everything even though those guys don't need one.
_________________________
Kawai C-60 Grand Piano : Hammond A-100 : Hammond SK2 : Yamaha CP4 : Yamaha Montage 7 : Moog Sub 37

My latest album: Funky organ, huge horn section
https://bobbycressey.bandcamp.com/album/cali-native

Top
#2901054 - 01/10/18 06:25 AM Re: Who of you play to a click? [Re: Bobadohshe]
drawback Offline
MP Hall of Fame Member

Registered: 05/11/04
Posts: 3428
Loc: Canada
^^
This. Most recording projects Iíve been involved with use a click for punch ins & edits.
_________________________
SL88 Studio / iMac [ MainStage | VI Ravenscroft 275 | EW Steinway D | UVI Rhodes ]
Mojo61 / Korg PlugKey / iPhone [ Ravenscroft iOS | Module | Scarbee ]

Top
#2901060 - 01/10/18 06:48 AM Re: Who of you play to a click? [Re: Bobadohshe]
MorayM Offline
Platinum Member

Registered: 09/05/13
Posts: 1444
Loc: Wilts, UK
We use one for all but three tracks (guess which three!) in my Floyd band. But it's more for logistical reasons than anything else. Mostly it means we can sync videos, lights, and sound effects to the performance but also because we're often very spread out across the stage it's difficult to "feel" the tempo changes like you do in a smaller space.
_________________________
North Haverbrook - Godsticks - SoundCloud

Top
#2901095 - 01/10/18 08:14 AM Re: Who of you play to a click? [Re: MorayM]
ElmerJFudd Offline
MP Hall of Fame Member

Registered: 11/30/14
Posts: 5978
Loc: USA, greater NY area
I also used to do this to keep band size small to keep pay higher for a quartet. I sequenced keys string and brass parts on an MC-50mkII and threw a U220 in a rack. I played guitar and we had vocal bass and acoustic drums. The band was tight with or without the songs that used the click (which was sent to drummer over headphones). And this was a pop rock band covering stuff that is recorded to click to begin with. So it was fine.

That said, no play in tempo is lame for many styles of music that were not created with the computer grid to begin with. You can fall into a rut playing the same songs in the same order the same way all the time. You do add an added element for a tech glitch. And sometimes the energy in the room calls for a different song a different tempo another time around on the chorus or solo etc. So itís great for some stuff but not for others in a nutshell.
_________________________
Live: Yamaha S90ES, Roland VR-700
Home: Rebuilt 1910 Chickering 5'2", Fender Rhodes MKI 88k

Top
#2901104 - 01/10/18 08:30 AM Re: Who of you play to a click? [Re: ElmerJFudd]
Theo Verelst Offline
MP Hall of Fame Member

Registered: 02/27/10
Posts: 3839
Remember that (early) Steinberg Cubase (Pro 24) sound coming from the computer" BLIEP bliep bliep bliep, BLIEP ....

My problem with a click track is that the phases of the subsequent clicks/bips get a rhythm meaning, and even a percussive meaning in terms of their relative phases playing through a real or virtual reverberation setting. So without work and specific tempi they even sound crude and unnecessarily rude as a tempo as well as the ensemble coming from the envelope of the click instrument usually is extremely limited as rhythmic indicator with space for human interaction.

So, many years, in fact a few decades ago, I practiced with click and Drum Computer to raise my awareness of rhythmic steadfastness, turning on being able to set a reasonable rhythm as imitation of simple drum patterns, and finally I got to the point of feeling self assured at various types of rhythm keeping as player or practicing songs.

Then, after listening to and playing Jazz/Fusion, I can be too easily bored with a Rock rhythm from bad drum computer or computer track that doesn't acknowledge anything from playing style mapped to the click instrument to sampling issues that I hear through any reasonable reverb tail as highly annoying.

T.

Top
#2901107 - 01/10/18 08:56 AM Re: Who of you play to a click? [Re: Theo Verelst]
wineandkeyz Offline
Gold Member

Registered: 02/06/06
Posts: 576
Loc: North Carolina
I used to fill in with a band that used IEMs and played to a click and backing vocal tracks on every song. It worked pretty well in that tempos were always spot on, etc. The singer had even inserted little cues to help keep track of where we were ("Guitar solo ends in 4... 3... 2... 1...").

The thing I found strange -- or at least I wondered if anyone in the audience noticed -- is that the two-bar count-in was in our ears; No one gave a four count or whatever. So, we'd be standing there doing whatever and all just coincidentally start each song at the same time.
_________________________
LIVE: Yamaha S70XS; Roland Jupiter-80; Nord Electro 4D; Spacestation V3 or Traynor K4
HOME: Yamaha S90ES; Hammond XK3C & Neo Vent; Roland Fantom X7; Arp Odyssey
QUIK-LOK X STANDS!

Top
#2901109 - 01/10/18 09:01 AM Re: Who of you play to a click? [Re: Theo Verelst]
Reezekeys Offline
MP Hall of Fame Member

Registered: 02/07/11
Posts: 2539
Loc: NYC area
If you use a click on a live gig because you need help keeping the tempo from shifting, then I don't know what to say. In my experience, with the bands and players I work with, a click is almost always used only by the drummer and for just a few specific reasons: 1) to synchronize with a pre-record that the band is playing with, or 2) the song needs to be played at a very specific tempo and the drummer (or whoever counts it off) must be as accurate as possible in counting off the song. In that case the click is only used to help with the count-in, after which it's shut off. This is what I've seen anyway.

In the studio of course it's a different story. I've played to a click track occasionally and the reason is that it's usually a pop tune that's gonna get worked on in a DAW and having the live playing line up with the bars & beats helps greatly for editing and laying in new stuff.

Top
#2901111 - 01/10/18 09:11 AM Re: Who of you play to a click? [Re: JimboK]
davedoerfler Online   confused
KCFF League Champion 2017
MP Hall of Fame Member

Registered: 12/27/12
Posts: 7140
Loc: thin ice
Originally Posted By: JimboK

Anyone else do this or are we cheating horribly?


good thing you asked us this, Jim, and not Warren Haynes. laugh

_________________________
In all seriousness, whatever works for you is absolutely the way to go.
dB

Top
#2901118 - 01/10/18 09:39 AM Re: Who of you play to a click? [Re: davedoerfler]
Moonglow Online   content
MP Hall of Fame Member

Registered: 03/15/03
Posts: 4547
Loc: Northwest Indiana
Our drummer plays to a click, the rest of us canít hear it. I have our sound guy turn up the high hat in my monitor, which the drummer keeps going through most of our songs, especially during sections where there are no drums. I really like it and find that it helps keep me locked in.

I like the OPís ďexcitement speedĒ reference, never heard that term before. Last year we had a gig at a large festival (approx. 2000 people) and we briefly huddled after our first set and everyone, except our drummer, felt the tempos were seriously dragging. Our drummer said something like, ďno guys, we were right on tempo.Ē A few days later when we listened to a recording of our performance we discovered he was correct. Turns out we were so jacked up we felt everything was slow. We were fortunate that he reeled us in.


Edited by Moonglow (01/10/18 06:52 PM)
Edit Reason: Added content.
_________________________
"We don't stop playing because we grow old; we grow old because we stop playing."
- George Bernard Shaw

Top
#2901124 - 01/10/18 10:05 AM Re: Who of you play to a click? [Re: Moonglow]
Delaware Dave Offline
MP Hall of Fame Member

Registered: 04/21/11
Posts: 2928
Loc: Take a guess ....
My B3 has key click, does that count?
_________________________
57 Hammond B3; 69 Hammond L100P; 68 Leslie 122; Kurzweil PC3; GEM Equinox; Voce V5+; Neo Vent; EV ELX112P; GSI Gemini Desktop Module; dyinbreedband.com; thewildthingsrock.webs.com

Top
#2901136 - 01/10/18 10:53 AM Re: Who of you play to a click? [Re: I-missRichardTee]
area51recording Offline
Platinum Member

Registered: 12/13/02
Posts: 1836
Loc: Newburgh,IN
Originally Posted By: I-missRichardTee

Another comment... It is indelible in my mind, the day a new singer subbed for our regular singer. The profound effect the new singer had on the groove... if you had asked me this, I would have said, no way, can a singer influence groove the way a bass or drum can., but that sub singer showed me I was naive.. a melody person, has a huge effect on groove. Think your average tempo deficient singer,than fast forward to Sinatra or James Brown.


I share this opinion.....to me the biggest mistake vocalists (and horn players for that matter) make is forgetting that they are as responsible for the groove as the rhythm section....

Top
#2901159 - 01/10/18 12:35 PM Re: Who of you play to a click? [Re: area51recording]
harmonizer Offline
Gold Member

Registered: 08/11/06
Posts: 724
Loc: NJ, USA
Our covers band has occasionally done rehearsals to a click, back when the drummer we had was not as good at keeping a steady tempo. If we used the click for just half the songs in a rehearsal, we would notice the benefits to the band during the next rehearsal, even if the click was not used at that next rehearsal.

Top
#2901160 - 01/10/18 12:38 PM Re: Who of you play to a click? [Re: area51recording]
harmonizer Offline
Gold Member

Registered: 08/11/06
Posts: 724
Loc: NJ, USA
Originally Posted By: area51recording
....to me the biggest mistake vocalists (and horn players for that matter) make is forgetting that they are as responsible for the groove as the rhythm section....


During rehearsals when we used a click, we noticed that the click slowed down when we got to the 3-part harmonies in the chorus of songs. Previously we had no idea that this was happening.

Top
#2901184 - 01/10/18 01:40 PM Re: Who of you play to a click? [Re: harmonizer]
The Real MC Offline
MP Hall of Fame Member

Registered: 05/17/05
Posts: 4909
Loc: Secluded Tranquil NY Wine Coun...
Originally Posted By: drawback
^^
This. Most recording projects Iíve been involved with use a click for punch ins & edits.


I use a click track for recording for the same reason.

But never used one or needed one for live music. Never been in a situation where I needed backing tracks.

Top
#2901189 - 01/10/18 01:51 PM Re: Who of you play to a click? [Re: The Real MC]
timwat Offline
Quite wealthy...spiritually
MP Hall of Fame Member

Registered: 11/21/01
Posts: 5520
Loc: Concord,CA,UNITED STATES
Most (but not all) recording sessions where I've laid down rhythm section tracks are laid to click for reasons mentioned above.

Only one live act I sub in uses click - a tribute act with backing tracks (occasional orchestration and background vox).

In my anecdotal opinion, for live use it would depend greatly upon 1) caliber of musicians, as generally the better your bass & drummer, the better the internal sense of time, and 2) reliance upon tracks.
_________________________
"I'm not just untalented. I'm multi untalented."

Top
#2901229 - 01/10/18 04:09 PM Re: Who of you play to a click? [Re: JimboK]
CowboyNQ Offline
Gold Member

Registered: 06/14/15
Posts: 732
Loc: Adelaide, Australia
Originally Posted By: JimboK
Anyone else do this or are we cheating horribly?

We use a click for some songs in both my bands. In our case, it's either to sync with video or an arpeggiator. Only the drummers can hear it.

Top
#2901232 - 01/10/18 04:17 PM Re: Who of you play to a click? [Re: CowboyNQ]
David Loving Offline
MP Hall of Fame Member

Registered: 12/11/00
Posts: 5022
Loc: Texas
One band, the drummer uses a click. The other band, the drummer is a human click track.
_________________________
"Forget it, Jake. It's Chinatown."

Top
#2901243 - 01/10/18 05:32 PM Re: Who of you play to a click? [Re: David Loving]
KeyMoe Offline
Platinum Member

Registered: 01/11/09
Posts: 1252
Loc: Texas
Our country band uses a click but only to the drummer. Keeps tempos correct.
_________________________
Montage 8, Mojo 61, PC-3, ES-7, CX3, XK-3c Pro, XV-88, Fantom X-7, Kronos 88, Hammond SK-1, Motif XF- 7, PC361, Hammond SK-2, Roland FR-1, FR-1X, Hammond B3 - Blond, Hammond BV -Cherry

Top
#2901246 - 01/10/18 05:46 PM Re: Who of you play to a click? [Re: harmonizer]
PianoMan51 Offline
Gold Member

Registered: 02/02/10
Posts: 967
Loc: Cabin In The Woods
Originally Posted By: harmonizer
Originally Posted By: area51recording
....to me the biggest mistake vocalists (and horn players for that matter) make is forgetting that they are as responsible for the groove as the rhythm section....


During rehearsals when we used a click, we noticed that the click slowed down when we got to the 3-part harmonies in the chorus of songs. Previously we had no idea that this was happening.


Exactly! I play gigs with a singer-drummer who always speeds up when he starts to sing. His perspective, I suspect, is that we get slower during those sections.

Top
#2901247 - 01/10/18 05:47 PM Re: Who of you play to a click? [Re: KeyMoe]
hardware Offline
Platinum Member

Registered: 03/04/14
Posts: 1232
Loc: Las Vegas
Many of us grew up playing to a blinking silent red light on a metronome in the dark.
Clicks to drummers ears are fine if they donít care.
A great modern method is Audio/click to a 128 LED Monome.
You can see colored subdivisions, it is easier to groove and drummers turned me onto this ten years ago.

Set it up like a monitor wedge.
Lots of fun doing ritardandos too.
I used Reaper and Cubase and it worked great.

Visual brings back days of Chopin and Bill Evans studies.
The Conservatory I went to had red light pyramids in every room.
_________________________
Magnus C350 + FMR RNP + Realistic Unisphere Mic

Top
#2901269 - 01/10/18 07:09 PM Re: Who of you play to a click? [Re: hardware]
JimboK Offline
Senior Member

Registered: 03/04/08
Posts: 348
Loc: California
Interesting comments all. Good to hear all the ways they are (and aren't) used.

I thought for sure that having click in anyone but the drummer's ears would be an issue but lead guitar and bass really wanted them. We have IEM's with individual mixes, so no biggie to accomplish. I added some to my mix and I love it. When the drummer is playing, the click is drowned out. However, when I start a song, I can play to the click and the rest of the band falls in effortlessly.

So far, so good.
_________________________
Korg Kronos 61, Dave Smith Mopho x4, 1954 Hammond C2, Wurlitzer 200A, Yamaha Motif 6, Casio CDP-100, Alesis Vortex Wireless

Top
Page 1 of 2 1 2 >


Moderator:  Dave Bryce, Stephen Fortner