What Dan Duran said. It may even seem alright, but if there is any cold soldering, it won't work properly. Once I had something like this on my Peavey Foundation P/J (And, mind you, right after I installed the Bartolini P/J set!) and when I rolled off the volume on the "P" pickup, it went dim, but never "off". It was that I had a cold soldering on the 3rd leg of the pot (the one I had to the ground). Cleaned the old solder, using the solder hot tip, a little bit of soldering flux on the pot's outer case andthen polished it a bit with a Dremel metal brush tip, and re-soldered it with fresh material. It works smoothly now.