Dave Pierce
MP Hall of Fame Member
Registered: 04/24/02
Posts: 3212
Loc: San Jose, CA
Yeah, scottasin, that's pretty much what I still hate about my Electro. I mean, I love everything else, but I really miss drawbars.
John Medeski is just a freak of nature though. The stuff this guy does live is from another dimension or something. My buddy had front-row tickets to their show a couple of years ago and I got to go with him. I was completely blown away by his playing.
--Dave
_________________________
Make my funk the P-funk. I wants to get funked up.
Thanks for posting this. Not generally a fan of much of their music that I've heard in the past, but that was indeed a great organ solo and I enjoyed the whole thing quite a bit.
_________________________
Yamaha P250, Voce V-5, Hammond Xk-3, Muse Receptor, 2 EV sxa360's, Speakeasy RBIII w/ AMA, Hammond M-3,Farfisa VIP, RMI electric piano,Kurzweil K2000, Young Chang 6'0" Grand, Melodica, Nord Electro 3
#2129516 - 10/28/0908:59 PMRe: Nice drawbar technique
[Re: Ian Benhamou]
B3Nut
Senior Member
Registered: 04/09/01
Posts: 380
Loc: Mount Horeb, WI USA
LOLOL!!!! Great tune, really bitchin' organ solo, and what an ending!
Yeah, this is where my Electro2 and I fall out. The night I finally got to take my B-3 to a gig with my current band, I felt liberated. I love to work the bars when I play, those buttons are a pain in the rear. I just can't warm up to them at all, and I've had the thing for over a year.
Karl Schmeer
Senior Member
Registered: 11/09/08
Posts: 72
Loc: St. Louis
That was cool. I agree Mogut. A lot of it seems "not intentional" or practiced. But some of it could be useful to borrow. Yep,tried it on my E2. A player could never move those simulated button/drawbars fast enough. I just spent the summer recording my band. It's nice to know everyone yells fxxx at the end of a song. - Karl
_________________________
I would never join a club that would have me as a member! G. Marx
frogmonkey
Senior Member
Registered: 01/12/09
Posts: 219
Loc: northeast USA
Yeah, I've been running into the same wall with the E3. Fortunately, I just got got delivery of Outkaster's Voce drawbars yesterday! I'm still waiting on my event processor, though, so they're not talking the same language as the E3 yet.
I'm a big fan. Saw them twice and Medeski's left hand was always on drawbars or on the Clavinet to support the groove. His settings and hammond sounds are awsome IMHO
LOLOL!!!! Great tune, really bitchin' organ solo, and what an ending!
Yeah, this is where my Electro2 and I fall out. The night I finally got to take my B-3 to a gig with my current band, I felt liberated. I love to work the bars when I play, those buttons are a pain in the rear. I just can't warm up to them at all, and I've had the thing for over a year.
If it means a lot to you (and it does to me) get a Voce V-5 or similar drawbar unit and a midi solutions event processor to map the cc#'s. Now I have physical drawbars for my upper manual settings on my Electro 3 and only use the buttons for the lower manual. Has made things much nicer for me. I did already own the drawbars, though.
_________________________
Yamaha P250, Voce V-5, Hammond Xk-3, Muse Receptor, 2 EV sxa360's, Speakeasy RBIII w/ AMA, Hammond M-3,Farfisa VIP, RMI electric piano,Kurzweil K2000, Young Chang 6'0" Grand, Melodica, Nord Electro 3
#2129704 - 10/29/0911:17 AMRe: Nice drawbar technique
[Re: Joe P]
Joe Muscara
Double Secret Banninated
MP Hall of Fame Member
Registered: 02/21/05
Posts: 4262
Loc: Houston, TX
There's a guy I think who is on the Electro Yahoo! group who is building drawbars for Electros. He hasn't started selling them yet, but has posted videos of them working. They look pretty cool. They get their power from the MIDI bus (at least on the E2. One delay is he's trying to reduce the voltage requirement so it will use bus power on the E3), and are live. That means the lights are in sync with the drawbars, and when you switch back to organ mode, the drawbar position matches.
#2129768 - 10/29/0901:23 PMRe: Nice drawbar technique
[Re: Joe Muscara]
New&Improv
Gold Member
Registered: 02/27/07
Posts: 502
Great clip! I'm a big Medeski fan, but this is the first time I've been able to really focus on what he's doing on the drawbars, I find it a very expressive and intentional approach. On one of Joe Doria's instructional vids, he talks about how hammond playing feels like "pushing buttons" at first, but eventual it becomes expressive technique, I think this was a good example of that.
_________________________
Turn up the speaker Hop, flop, squawk It's a keeper -Captain Beefheart, Ice Cream for Crow
Jaime Chimuelo
Senior Member
Registered: 01/26/09
Posts: 88
That's a great video. Unfortunately B3 lovers w/o a crew have to use different instruments. I just wanted to let guys know who have Nords that there are other ways to use drawbars besides the one handed techniques. There's these DSP cards called Creamware that have an awesome B3 Physically modelled. Their synths. mixers and effects are excellent too, but a 300 Luna or a 500 Project card from ebay used is a wise investment and here's why. First the sound is authentic, the Rotary is pretty good for an EMU but I am an X Hammond player and use a Pro3t so I get pretty close to a B3 sound. But w/ the B2003 model one can use a CC Device that has 8 virtual faders. Each fader can be attached to a virtual drawbar. Each fader also has 3 controls. One for starting point of the fader ( drawbar ) and one for the end point. Then the curves can be chosen, linear, linear R, Exponential, Exponential R, Logarithmic, and Log R. Then there's the lagtime which is the showstopper. You end up ganging all of these to an expression pedal. On top of the expression pedal is a velcroed footswitch pedal. You push forward with your heel and swell the drawbar combinations to go from where you start to stop, the footswitch is easy to step on while moving to control the speeds. But the beauty of this is the global Lag time can be used also. This means while we are busy using both hands to perform, a fast stomp on the expression pedal activates the controls and even though you just stomped the pedal from all the way back to forward the lag time still controls the destination times for the drawbars. It's pretty awesome to use live. If I knew how to post pics I'd show you, but trust me, I am an old B3 player and when I lost management the B3 was nothing but a problem. The Anvil case lid was pulled off and the b3 rolled out on stage and it seemed so easy. But w/o a crew you're dead in the water. I also use a MIDI solutions F8 to have 8 1/4" pedal I/O's. I use 5 of the footswitches to change keyswitched string and horn articulations. Don't know where you guys gig at, but at my jobs 2 hands are used or you are looking for work. It's a challenge I rose up to years ago when I started doing showrooms and lounges again, I had it made when I was just a keyboard guy and had management. In the lounges I am expected to cover horns, strings and even Guitars. It's true, the shittier the jobs and the less pay, the harder we have to work. I often dream of making a cut out of myself and getting Cubase to play everything while I bang waittail cocktresses............ooops, I meant to say Cocktail waitresses.....a Freudian slip....
Wastrel
Senior Member
Registered: 05/13/09
Posts: 167
Loc: Los Angeles
For quite a while now, I've had a Nord Electro on my GAS list. I'm starting to get cold feet though listening to all you guys bitch about the buttons... I never did that much real time diddling with the drawbars on my B3, but I did change my settings fairly often - like 4 or 5 times during a song. Suppose I wanted to go from 888850023 to 888888888 quickly for emphasis and back again which is basically just a grab and pull/push operation on a B3, would I have to sit there and watch the LEDs ramp up and down on the Nord or is it pretty responsive?
Registered: 10/30/07
Posts: 205
Loc: Mount Juliet, TN
Originally Posted By: Wastrel
Suppose I wanted to go from 888850023 to 888888888 quickly for emphasis and back again which is basically just a grab and pull/push operation on a B3, would I have to sit there and watch the LEDs ramp up and down on the Nord or is it pretty responsive?
It's pretty responsive, but you could always store drawbar presets too & those are really quick to grab.
_________________________
Yamaha P22 Upright / Nord Stage 76 RevC / Rhodes Mark V / Roland VK8 / Roland JV1080
B3-er
Platinum Member
Registered: 06/04/02
Posts: 1504
Loc: Lansing, MI
Those drawbar movements are completely intentional. He knows exactly what he's doing. I do something similar if the mood strikes, moreso when I'm playing with a bassist.
Bridog6996
Platinum Member
Registered: 01/19/05
Posts: 1749
The Electro buttons take some getting used to, for sure, but they're pretty responsive. You have replace the sort-of push/pull grabbing technique with "button mash" technique. Still would prefer drawbars 100%, but the buttons are very usable IMO.
Outkaster
Platinum Member
Registered: 02/25/06
Posts: 1184
Loc: Rochester, NY
Originally Posted By: Wastrel
For quite a while now, I've had a Nord Electro on my GAS list. I'm starting to get cold feet though listening to all you guys bitch about the buttons... I never did that much real time diddling with the drawbars on my B3, but I did change my settings fairly often - like 4 or 5 times during a song. Suppose I wanted to go from 888850023 to 888888888 quickly for emphasis and back again which is basically just a grab and pull/push operation on a B3, would I have to sit there and watch the LEDs ramp up and down on the Nord or is it pretty responsive?
Karl Schmeer
Senior Member
Registered: 11/09/08
Posts: 72
Loc: St. Louis
Well a bit of crow sandwich is in order. After listening to this vid on decent speakers I can hear the more subtle aspects of John's drawbar technique. Still I estimate that it takes about a half second to get the Nord drawbar all the way out or in, so you could never do all of this on a NE2/3 without a midi drawbar controller. Don't get me wrong. I love my NE2. It sounds so good, I can't stop playing it.
My apologies John
- Karl
_________________________
I would never join a club that would have me as a member! G. Marx
#2130954 - 11/03/0902:27 AMRe: Nice drawbar technique
[Re: Karl Schmeer]
Tusker
MP Hall of Fame Member
Registered: 08/02/00
Posts: 4603
Loc: Saddle Ridge
Personally, I think those movements aren't conscious ... they are in muscle memory ... much as velocity control is for a pianist. It's really nice to see someone playing in that zone.
You can do drawbar stuff on the electro that is impossible on a B3. (The rhythmic clicking thing would be similar to Josef Z hitting the octave +- buttons, or Tony B hitting the Prophet 5 preset buttons with one hand while playing with the other.)
It's a different statement, but it's good if it's used in the service of the music. imo