Hi Ethan,
I've been doing some tests for a few weeks now in my small room (12'x10') and I've had the opportunity to try several models of speaker ranging in size and price. One thing I've noticed pretty much consistently is a band between 100 and about 300Hz where a great deal of life seems to be sucked out of the frequency response.
My room is what we call in the UK plasterboard (US drywall?) over breeze block (US cinder block?).
Now, my theory: do you think this kind of board over cavity construction could be acting as a kind of panel trap and damping these frequencies? I never had these issues in a previous home that had a similar sized room but with solid walls although it was a different shape,
many thanks again for your time
Tim