Maybe I'm missing something. Seems like there should be a forum called "Original Recordings For Critique" something of that nature. I'm a recording hobbyist and I have some of my songs on Mp3.com. I've always wished though, that there was a forum where I could post (works in progress) and get feedback from people with more experience than myself.
Is there a forum like this somewhere?
Try the thread that is currently just a few lines below this one called "Let's Hear It". I believe that may be what you are looking for...please feel free to post your stufff there.
If you don't mind a recommendation, the best way to get results is to listen to other people's stuff, and share your comments on their works as well.